Tag Archives: Columbus Day

Happy…Columbus Day?

Posted by the US Department of War,
not yet legally an official title by statute, although it is used as an official secondary title across the executive branch.

If interested, here are my thoughts on Columbus Day after seeing the Department of War’s post. (This does not necessarily reflect the beliefs of any of the organizations I am part of. Any errors are mine.) In short, the holiday has historic and ongoing value, but it comes with baggage too. I know that I have written about this before.

The holiday is complicated by Christopher Columbus’ mixed legacy – brave perhaps, benefiting trade and modernization, but it also comes to us stained with the very real harms of colonization, slavery and genocidal acts. Why do Italians hang onto it?

Italians, especially from the South and Sicily, looked different (often dark-skinned), spoke differently, and were of a feared faith, Roman Catholicism. They were often the new working poor and unaccepted. Jobs, housing and education were often denied, and slum living or unofficial villages near rivers became a norm of sorts.

Unfortunately, false accusations and violence came too late. Eleven Italian immigrants became accused of killing the New Orleans police chief. History states that most had been rounded up due to their ethnicity. Accusations arose that organized crime was trying to influence the government. The word “mafia” moved into the US lexicon for reportedly the first time. An angry mob did not accept the judgement of acquittal for several of the men. The largest mass lynching in the history of the United States was the result.

Initially the press was quite supportive of the lynchers. Theodore Roosevelt, I’ve read, actually sent a private letter to someone commending what happened. Yet as Italian organizations complained and an angry Italian government’s diplomatic responses began to have effect, the xenophobic verbosity lessened.

As you can read in the Wikipedia article about this incident, it appears that President Harrison instituted Columbus Day on the 400th Anniversary of his voyage (1892) to partly help placate both Italy and Italians in the United States. President Harrison even agreed to pay a $25,000 indemnity to the victims’ families. (Which Congress unsuccessfully tried to derail.) Unfortunately, the death of the police chief became a rallying cry to nativists.

[Updated on 11/3/2026: Since first posting this, I have been reading several social media posts arguing that the above information is incorrect. They say, often with the similar wording. “President Harrison made a standard anniversary proclamation. There is no written evidence that the actions were in any way connected.” Certainly, there appears a debate over this, but I would like to suggest that the inherited view of Italians should not be so quickly dismissed. From what I have seen, the social media proponents often view the Italian as clearly white European and thus part of the majority white European culture. Based on the above, I argue that argument is too simplistic. Just as other minorities should be listened to by the dominant culture when speaking about their history, the same standard should hold here. My ancestors and others, including advocates for Italian rights at the time, viewed the events as connected. This does not necessitate a direct link or paper trail. What I am arguing, echoing my inherited stories, is that the protests by Italy and Italian American groups after the hangings made a difference. Such arguments denying this strip dignity from those past sacrifices and voices. Again, Italians including my family members faced overt racism and xenophobia impacting housing, jobs, and education. Italians of the time understood the start of Columbus Day was connected to the mass hanging and subsequent protests even if not in writing. Maybe we should consider their contemporary understanding past down through generations as we should do with other ethnic groups and races.]

As prejudice and racist acts continued, Italians leaned into their faith and cultural celebrations. They welcomed Columbus Day as a hopeful sign. Many of the hated or even toppled statues of Columbus (including in Virginia) were put up as a claim to a new homeland and as a request for respect and recognition as equals. They often were put up despite overt threats and sometimes violent acts including bombings and attacks on Catholic Churches and universities from the KKK and others. The statues went up anyway as paid for through the donations of immigrant families.

[Updated on 11/3/2026: For example, the oldest Columbus statue in the South was the monument to Columbus raised in Richmond. it was also the first statue to have night illumination. Italian families paid for it in full even as they heard of overt threats from the KKK. In a sad irony, because of Columbus’ undeniable colonizing past, it became a symbol hated by those in the Black Lives Matter protests. “On June 9, 2020, a statue of Christopher Columbus in Richmond’s Byrd Park became one of many monuments to the explorer toppled by protesters around the world following George Floyd’s murder.” (See The meaning of Columbus, his image and history continue to evolve.) Why was it erected in Byrd Park on December 9, 1927? The city was not willing to have it on Monument Avenue. As the above cited article reports, nativism and intense anti-immigrant sentiment shaped the decision. Much of that was directed at Italian and Jewish immigrants — or anyone who was “deemed not sufficiently white or not Protestant, not of Anglo-Saxon origin.” An article in the Catholic Virginian by Bishop Barry Nestout also suggests anti-Catholic prejudice and a desire to protect the perceived “sanctity” of Monument Avenue played a part. He quotes an earlier article arguing, “According to Harry Kollatz Jr., writing in the October 2014 Richmond Magazine, the Patriotic Welfare Committee ‘decried Columbus as a foreigner, a Roman Catholic, and wrongly credited as finding the New World. They gave the Vikings that credit.’” After being torn down, set on fire, and thrown into Fountain Lake, Richmond’s statue was recovered, refurbished, and relocated to the Rockland Lodge Order of the Sons of Italy in September 2024.]

In truth, the Italian’s lot in the United States did not progress much until WW2 when so many vets came home with an appreciation for Italian food, culture and sometimes wives. New Italian restaurants and Americano coffees became an acceptable thing. Then came Dean Martin, Frank Sinatra and others. Like rap music, it caught the imagination of white youth and changed attitudes. (It’s important to note that particularly Sicilians and Southern Italians before this time were not considered white in the South.)

As I indicate above, my and my wife’s relatives faced overt discrimination in education, jobs and housing in the North. This was in the 1920s through the 1950s. To ignore why Columbus was adopted as a symbol silences people wounded in the past – some wounds carried into later generations. Yet recognizing the historical facts, perhaps just changing the name of the holiday to Italian Appreciation Day would prove a help. Yet I hope we don’t forget about this ugly past and learn from it. We need to remember it and Columbus – what he did (both good and bad) certainly, but why he became this icon – especially as we interact with new immigrants and their stories today. This link leads to a history video on Facebook about the connection: https://lnkd.in/eqa3KNiR.

As for the War Department’s post, Hegseth is using the post to stir the pot with identity politics because he too often acts like a hard hearted child. From my experience and training, people in AA might think him a “dry drunk.” He seems to have many unresolved issues from his alcoholism still harming himself, others, and our national security. His denomination is an angry, unhealthy one – overtly Christian Nationalist, many suggesting it has cult like leanings. These posts misusing scripture and inappropriately addressing “culture wars” are distractions when there are real dangers to address. I do pray for his repentance and growth toward personal peace with himself and others – although he’d scoff at me for that. He believes empathy is weak and a sin. I believe he is very unhealthy.

People might think this is inappropriate territory for a pastor, but I’m speaking this in love for him and others, not for punishment or degradation. He’s settling for a counterfeit version of the abundant life Jesus offers the entire universal Church. It’s called Christian nationalism. This is a stated desire by leaders of his denomination, dangerous to democracy and easily confirmed.

Indigenous People’s Day need not be put in competition with other cultures. That’s suspiciously looking to be the background intention of the War Department’s post even as it remains a Federal Holiday. As a simple Google search identified: “The U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) did not issue a dedicated Indigenous Peoples’ Day social media post or public statement for October 12, 2026.” And recently with changes to rules regarding chaplains and faith, “The update removed the distinct “Native American Religion” category (along with 179 other specific faiths), placing service members whose specific beliefs are not individually listed under the “Other Religion” category for dog tags, military records, and chaplain services.”

Indigenous People’s Day meets a real need and stands on its own merits, as it should. I accept the need for it to supersede or overshadow my Italian celebration of culture. Italians have come a long way. I’ve benefited from the sacrifices of those that came before me. Now, others need the attention to help them find justice, acceptance and progress. It doesn’t mean I can’t still celebrate my ancestors too even if on the same day.

© 2026 The Rev. Louis Florio. All content not held under another’s copyright may not be used without permission of the author unless under terms of fair use and properly attributed. Scripture passages when used are from the NRSVue translation unless otherwise indicated. Edited for clarity and some content on November 3, 2026.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized